Should Blood Doping Methods be Legalized
for Use in Sports Competitions?
   

Background: Athletes can use a variety of blood doping techniques to improve their performance especially in such
endurance sports as cycling, swimming, running and cross country skiing.



Red Blood Cells
whyfiles.org/090doping_sport/ images/redblood.jpg

Basic Description of Blood Doping: Oxygen is carried throughout the body by erythrocytes also known as red blood cells (RBCs). Hemoglobin in red blood cells carry up to 97% of the total oxygen in the body . After strenuous exercise the body builds up lactic acid because of a lack of oxygen. This lactic acid causes the muscles to fatigue,cramp and become sore (1). Obviously there are huge benefits to any substance that helps the body transport more oxygen around the body.

Athletes can improve their performance by increasing their body's capacity to carry additional oxygen. Methods include:

Increasing total volume of red blood cells-
Blood transfusion of athlete's own blood: The athlete takes out 1-4 pints of his/her own blood several weeks before a major competition which forces the body to make more blood. Additionally, the athlete reinjects the stored RBCs days before the competition (2).

Use of EPO to stimulate production of red blood cells: Erythropoetin (natural or recombinant ) is a hormone that makes the body produce more RBCs.

Abbreviated pregnancy: During pregnancy, the body naturally produces more EPOs. It is suspected that some females become pregnant to trigger such production (3).

Training at high altitude: Athletes naturally produce more RBCs at high altitudes.

Use of a high altitude sleep chamber: Thechamber is supposed to simulate high altitude conditions.

Use of artificial oxygen carriers: Perfluorocarbons (PFCs) are artificial oxygen carriers which have 4 fluoride groups that carry oxygen. There are also synthetic types of hemoglobin (4).

Bans on Blood Doping Techniques: The IOC (International Olympic Committee), the UCI (International Cycling Union), the NCAA (National Collegiate Athletic association) and FINA, are some of the sports organizations that have banned blood doping and the use of EPO.

Testing: It is difficult to detect blood doping because the substances are natural and are rapidly broken up by the body. The first test used looked at hematocrit levels for abnormal levels (43 for a healthy athlete, 50 is considered suspiciously high)(5). Blood profiles were used to see if there was an expected ratio of new RBCs to maturing RBCs. Blood and urine tests are used to look for the presence of recombinant products since analytical lab techniques can detect differences in the structure of the molecules. Most of these tests aren't "legally" conclusive and so instead of accusing the athlete of cheating, athletes are often put on a temporary health suspension until their hematocrits return to safer levels(6) .

Harmful Side Effects:
When blood is thickened because of extra red blood cells, the athlete runs an increased risk of blood clots, strokes, and heart attacks. Blood transfusions run the risk of HIV, AIDs, and other blood diseases. Artificial oxygen carriers can cause liver and kidney disease and other problems.

Footnotes:
1. "Sports Doping Methods." Sports Doping. 13 May 2002. <http://www.sportsdoping.com/sportsdoping/methods.html>
2. "Performance Enhancing Drugs." 14 May 2002. <http://sis.bris.ac.uk/~rm0697/DOPING.HTML>
3. "Sports Doping Methods." Sports Doping. 13 May 2002. <http://www.sportsdoping.com/sportsdoping/methods.html>
4. "Performance Enhancing Drugs." 14 May 2002. <http://sis.bris.ac.uk/~rm0697/DOPING.HTML>
5. Ibid.
6. Ibid.

Workscited

Back to Ethics Homepage

Adam Haley